Can You Replant Carrots That Have Been Pulled Too Early?

By Paul Smart •  Updated: 04/24/22 •  5 min read

Can You Replant Carrots That Have Been Pulled Too Early? Carrots are an extremely popular vegetable to grow in your garden at home, however, one of the common problems with growing carrots is that it is difficult to tell how big the carrots are unless you pull them out of the ground. So what do you do when you pull a carrot too early? Can you replant it?

Carrots that have been pulled too early can be replanted and they will continue to grow, however, if this does happen it is important to replant them immediately and ensure that soil is moist and the carrot can quickly recover from the disturbance. In most cases, you will observe that the foliage will die back a little, however, the plant will usually recover relatively quickly.

To avoid the carrots from being picked too early one of the methods that can be used is to remove a little bit of dirt around the top of the carrot to see whether it has developed a reasonable size. Typically, a carrot that is ready to be picked will have distinct shoulders on the root which is an indication that it has a reasonable diameter.

However, in cases where the carrot is still relatively undeveloped, it is important to recover the soil around the plant because exposure of the root to light likely will result in the top of the carrot becoming green later on. If this happens it is not the end of the world because you can still pick the carrot and remove the green part and eat it as normal.

How To Remove Carrots From The Soil

If you are like most gardeners you will have sown too many carrots close together which results in you having lots of carrots in close proximity. This overcrowding necessitates an early harvest of carrots to be taken. However, to ensure that the remaining carrots in the ground remain undisturbed you need to be careful about how you remove the carrots.

The safest way to minimize disturbance of the other carrots in the ground is to twist them out rather than pull them out as this will reduce the chances of an entire clump being pulled out by accident.

How To Improve The Germination Of Carrots

One of the other really common issues with carrots is that they often produced patchy germinations where you will have clumps of seeds that germinate together and then there are other areas where the plants do not come up at all. So what can you do to avoid this?

The main problem with sowing carrot seeds is that they are relatively slow to germinate and they require consistent moisture during the germination period to ensure that they start to grow. This can be difficult because the depth of the furrows that the carrot seeds are planted in are generally relatively shallow and therefore can dry out relatively quickly. However, there are a couple of things you can do which can ensure much more consistent germination.  

One of the most common approaches to germination of carrots is to either soak the seeds or even pre-germinate the seeds on paper towels.  

To do this the easiest way is to take a resealable Tupperware container and place the paper towel that has been soaked in water in the base of the container. The paper towel should be damp but not sodden. To ensure that this is the case it is best to wet the paper towel and then ring it out with your hands until you can no longer squeeze any more moisture out of the towel. 

The seeds can then be sprinkled onto the surface of the towel and the sealed container can be left for approximately 5 to 7 days. By this point, you should be able to see the carrot seeds beginning to sprout at which point they can be transferred into the garden.

However, when transferring the seeds into the garden it can be a little bit tricky as they do not spread out as easily as the dry seeds. One of the methods that you can employ that will eliminate this problem is to sow the seeds on to the paper towel in lines at a similar rate to what you would sow them into a farrow.  These lines can then be separated by cutting the paper towel into strips. 

The strips of paper towel can then be removed with the seeds on them and placed into the furrows as the paper will not interfere with the growth of the carrots.

When planting the carrot seeds into the garden it is a good idea to create the furrows first and then water the soil thoroughly before adding the pre-germinated seeds this will ensure that the soil is moist which should get the carrots off to a good start.

In the early stages of the carrots’ growth, it is really important to ensure that you provide the plants with plenty of moisture to ensure that they continue to develop into strong plants.

The amount of moisture that is added to the carrots can be reduced once the plants become established, however, it is still important to regularly water the plants as inconsistent watering can result in the roots cracking over time.

I hope you found this article useful and you have great success growing your carrots at home, if you have any additional questions or comments please leave them in the section below.

Relevant Articles 

Should You Fertilize Carrots?

How Many Carrots Grow From One Seed?

Are Green Carrots Safe To Eat? What can I Do To Stop Them From Turning Green?

Why Are My Carrots So Hairy?

How Deep Do Carrots Grow? Does The Type Matter?

Paul Smart